Medicare fraud
Subscribe to Medicare fraud's Posts

Eighth Circuit Rejects FCA Claim for Failure to Allege Actual Claims for Payment

On February 11, 2019, the Eighth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a group of relators’ qui tam suit against Crawford County Memorial Hospital for failure to meet the pleading standards required by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 9(b). The court’s decision focused on the relators’ failure to allege the specifics of any actual claim for payment by Crawford County – a solid confirmation that the Eighth Circuit continues to require the pleading of identifiable false claims for payment, even in instances in which a relator is not in a position to have that information. The three relators were a former EMT and two former paramedics at Crawford County. The relators alleged that Crawford County violated the FCA by submitting, among other things, claims for breathing treatments administered to patients by paramedics, claims for lab services performed by paramedics and EMTs, and claims with false credentials of service providers. The relators further stated that...

Continue Reading

Use of Statistical Sampling to Establish Damages in FCA Cases Still Controversial

As we previously posted, on April 28, 2015, the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida in U.S. ex rel. Ruckh v. Genoa Healthcare LLC et al, held that expert testimony based on statistical sampling was appropriate in False Claims Act (FCA) cases and could not be excluded solely due to the concern that sampling, by its nature, subverts individualized proof. The court did, however, preserve the importance of Daubert motions to assail a purported sample, noting that defects in methodology or other evidentiary defects could still result in exclusion of an expert’s sampling analysis. Given the difficulties inherent in identifying a reliable sample in FCA cases involving issues of individualized proof, effective Daubert challenges to a relator’s or the government’s sampling expert are critical when litigating in courts that are inclined to permit sampling, whether offered to prove liability or damages. In Ruckh, the relator alleged that the...

Continue Reading

BLOG EDITORS

STAY CONNECTED

TOPICS

ARCHIVES